By Michael Koresky
Dir. Woody Allen, U.S., Sony Pictures Classics
The case could be made that Woody Allen is largely responsible for the word neurotic being a punch line. From Annie Hall and Manhattan onward, this urbane American artist has sketched a landscape in which characters teeter on the edge of emotional instability for our smiling pleasure. Those two early films are superb test cases for the possibilities and limits of personality disorder and chronic dissatisfaction as viable comedy; both are bemused by the ironic tragedy of people destined to be malcontented in the only city in which they could possibly survive. Luckily, these charactersâ€”all based in some part on the writer-director himself, now an archetypeâ€”offer a form of neurosis thatâ€™s wonderfully cinematic: verbose, expressive, given to fits of jealousy, anger, excitement, doubt, and occasional joy. When Allen has dared to venture into darker psychological portraiture (a.k.a, when heâ€™s â€śgone seriousâ€ť in films like Interiors and September), heâ€™s risked displeasing viewers whoâ€™d rather cozy to the relatably anxious than the genuinely depressed or dysfunctional.
The protagonist of his latest film, Jasmine, inhabited with fearsome commitment by Cate Blanchett, seems designed and performed to push the boundaries of audience engagement, albeit in an outwardly pleasant package; sheâ€™s his least adjusted main character since Deconstructing Harryâ€™s writer Harry Block, but without his creative outlet to fall back on. Unceremoniously plucked from her city, her income bracket, and the comfort afforded by her cultural myopia, Jasmine is a terrified fish out of water, constantly gasping for air in between gulps of martinis. Following the catastrophic unraveling of her life, initiated by the arrest of her financial titan husband, Hal (Alec Baldwin), for hoodwinking untold numbers of people with a Bernie Madoffâ€“like Ponzi scheme, Jasmine is transplanted from tony Upper West Side Manhattan to working-class San Francisco to move in with Ginger (Sally Hawkins), her half-sister (each was adopted from different biological parents). When we first meet Jasmine, sheâ€™s on a plane to the City by the Bay, chatting up a barely interested seatmate about her past and sex life; as weâ€™ll soon discover, her loquaciousness with strangers comes not from a generous desire to connect but from an increasingly troubling pathology. From the get-go, Jasmine is losing it, although our proximity to her, as the star of a Woody Allen film, leads us to believe in the essential adorability of her neuroses and therefore the possible reclamation of her selfhood. Blue Jasmine provocatively supposes that there may never have been a fully formed self to begin with.
Thereâ€™s an intriguing tonal disconnect to Allenâ€™s latest: as photographed by Vicky Cristina Barcelonaâ€™s Javier Aguirresarobe in deceptively warm, comic tones, it has the look and feel of the directorâ€™s more recent, airy adventures, yet it offers the single-minded, grim fatalism of many of his eighties films, inarguably his golden era. The somber, autumnal shades of Hannah and Her Sisters, September, Another Woman, and Crimes and Misdemeanors are missed here, and undoubtedly would have been welcome, yet Allen hasnâ€™t plunged into that aesthetic in many years. The pastel and powder-blue tones of Jasmineâ€™s journey reflect her desperate animation: Blanchett is constantly scattered, mentally and physically, and in terms of both movement and mood, Aguirresarobeâ€™s camera always seems to be playing catch-up. Though much of the film maintains the single-take, often static camera set-ups Allen prefers, both heâ€™s admitted out of fatigue and an aesthetic preference gleaned from the heady days of Ingmar Bergman, Aguirresarobe is allowed a few surprises, such as the unexpected, very slightly canted framing that captures Jasmine as she first arrives at Gingerâ€™s doorstep. Itâ€™s blink-and-miss-it brief, but notably unusual moment in an Allen film in which the camera takes on a characterâ€™s psychological disorientation, which is usually left up mostly to the actor to create.
Blanchett is surely up to that challenge, however. Imagine Judy Davisâ€™s Sally in Husbands and Wives having a movie all to herself, and that would give an idea of the unceasing display of nervous energy to which Blue Jasmine gives itself over. Blanchett often begins scenes looking like she just finished running an underwater marathon while downing shots of whiskey. Sheâ€™s skittish and jumpy, rattled by nearly everything, flinching as if every encounter might unleash her migraine; upon meeting Gingerâ€™s rambunctious preadolescent sons, she hilariously murmurs disgustedly, â€śTheyâ€™re big . . . theyâ€™re loud.â€ť Sheâ€™s never at ease in any situation, whether with family or strangers. Her constant, excessive drinking might strike as humorous if it werenâ€™t clearly an indication of a crippling alcoholism. Nevertheless, her neuroticism is oddly stoic, as if itâ€™s the last bastion of a former life made irrelevant; sheâ€™s unsettlingly self-sufficient, and Blanchettâ€™s essential coldness as an actor works perfectly here, as Jasmine doesnâ€™t seem bound for meaningful human connection.
She strikes a marked contrast to Hawkinsâ€™s Ginger, who projects a nervousness of a different order, always trying to impress others, whether itâ€™s Jasmine or any of the various men attached to her throughout the film, a series of loutish teddy bears played by such staunchly working-class types as Andrew â€śDiceâ€ť Clay, Louis C.K., and Bobby Cannavale. The casting of these three recognizably east coast guys (Clay is from Brooklyn; C.K. was born in D.C. yet is associated with New York from his sitcom; Cannavale is a Jersey boy) as northern California lotharios creates an immediate disjunction, but each brings a sizable helping of pathos to his part, especially Clay, who locates pockets of poignancy in a potentially stereotyped characterâ€”he tentatively paws at this perhaps unwarranted comeback role with a sense of palpable thwarted ambition. He plays Gingerâ€™s ex-husband, Augie, who turns up mostly in flashbacks meant to essay the fraught relationship between the half-sisters when their income disparity had been great. In one particularly well-observed scene, we learn that Hal paid for a hotel room for a visiting Ginger and Augie rather than let them stay in their palatial apartment; we also soon find out that the couple was among Halâ€™s swindled victims, as he encouraged Augie to invest money from a recent windfall into a â€ślow-risk, high-yield venture.â€ť (Baldwin, of course, can perform this cool persuasion in his sleep; wouldnâ€™t it have been refreshing to see him return to the kind of low-class lug he played in Working Girl, perhaps taking on Clayâ€™s role?)
Allenâ€™s films have often concerned themselves with the absurdities of the idle rich, sometimes explicitly (Alice), often implicitly (Hannah and Her Sisters), occasionally unthinkingly (Melinda and Melinda). Blue Jasmine, which like Alice is about the promises and risks of making a clean break from the leisured world of money, feels like his most empathetic work in this regard: stripped of everything by the government, Jasmine is poor, scared, one of us. This doesnâ€™t mean she finds her callingâ€”she can barely adjust; she doesnâ€™t know the lingo of everyday struggle, those financial negotiations that rule most of our lives. After arriving in San Francisco with her Louis Vuitton luggage, she announces that she flew first class; Ginger asks her how she could afford such a high-priced ticket if sheâ€™s as tapped out as she claims. Her hilariously unreal response: â€śI donâ€™t know. I just did.â€ť Allenâ€™s cinema may essentially be bourgeois, but itâ€™s rarely complacently so. Films such as Radio Days, Alice, Celebrity, and Match Point prove that money is never simply a given in Allenâ€™s work, neither is it something to strive towards. A structural foundation of his films has always been ambivalence (in regards to sex, romance, death), and thereâ€™s no reason this shouldnâ€™t extend to his take on privilege. Blue Jasmineâ€™s sharply divided portraits of affluence and struggle may be painted in broad strokes, but neither Jasmineâ€™s nor Gingerâ€™s values fall neatly into wealthy versus poor dichotomies of corrupt and wise, materialist and earthy.
One of Jasmineâ€™s most endearing, humanizing traits is that she was co-opted into the rich life at an early age, dropping out of Boston University to marry Hal and thus giving up her pursuit of an anthropology degree. This provocative idea of an alternate-reality Jasmine hangs over the film. The narrative is constantly negotiating between past and present Jasmine, jumping back and forth in time to before and after the fall. She was clearly more in her element when surrounded by the finer things, yet Blanchett is careful not to play her as comfortable. Whether itâ€™s because of an underlying distrust of her social status or suspicion of her husbandâ€™s fidelity, Jasmine never appeared to be fully at ease, making this not easily readable as simply the story of a downfall. It was a life already unmoored. Allen withholds the details of Jasmineâ€™s initial breakdown in New York so that, when revealed, they function as a parallel climax with her ultimate combustion, the past and present building in tandem to a crescendo of trauma and humiliation.
Many will note Blue Jasmineâ€™s indebtedness to Tennessee Williamsâ€™s A Streetcar Named Desire (spotting the influences is a common, if dead-end, game when it comes to Woody Allen), likening Blanchettâ€™s disintegrating wraith-like visitor from an increasingly irrelevant social class to that faded southern belle Blanche DuBois. The comparison is persuasive, especially considering Blanchettâ€™s acclaimed recent stage rendering of Williamsâ€™s iconic character and the late-film revelation that Jasmine was subject to institutionalization and a dose of â€śEdisonâ€™s medicine,â€ť not to mention the touch of New Orleansâ€“style jazz during the opening credits. As Bergmanâ€™s Wild Strawberries was an important influence on one of Allenâ€™s finest films, Another Woman, Streetcar only provides a narrative shell here. Jasmine stands as a fully realized, thoroughly Woody Allen character, skirting redemption thanks to a brand of neurotic compulsion that Allen knows well. Jasmine doesnâ€™t rely on the kindness of strangers, she merely bends their ears. Blue Jasmine charts the slow process by which she alienates everyone around her, leaving her stranded, alone, humming along to a ghostly tune from a distant past. Annie Hallâ€™s Alvy Singer famously separated life into two exclusive categories: the â€śmiserableâ€ť and the â€śhorrible.â€ť We need kindred neurotic spirits to help us wend our way through it; in the world of Allenâ€™s films, the most frightening possibility would be to have no one to talk to.