Female Prisoner #701 Scorpion: Beast Stable / Female Prisoner #701 Scorpion: Grudge Song
Dir. Shunya Ito/ Yasuharu Hasebe
Media Blasters/ Tokyo Shock
by Nick Pinkerton
To most contemporary American moviegoers, actress Meiko Kaji is probably most recognizable through her singing voice: thatâ€™s her song ushering along the final head slice in Kill Bill Volume One. The tune is the theme to Kajiâ€™s legendary-in-video-store-circles action franchise, the quintet of hell-hath-no-fury-like-a-woman-scorned Scorpion films that she made for Toei studios, all released in 1972-73, and an admitted inspiration for Tarantinoâ€™s KB volumes, alongside Kajiâ€™s two genre high-watermark Lady Snowblood samurai pictures. As is so often the case, Tarantinoâ€™s references are impeccable, his execution bungledâ€”the KB movies, completely insulated in their bathysphere of allusions, and starring a beautiful actress whoâ€™s never been less beautifully photographed, are accidentally closer to Truffautâ€™s The Bride Wore Black.
The Scorpion films revolve around prisoner #701, Nami Matsushima (Kaji; she usually goes by Sasori or Matsuâ€”or â€śScorpion,â€ť in jailhouse lore), once a self-described â€śwoman like any other,â€ť (difficult to swallow for a number of reasons) now lethally hardened by the betrayal of a vice detective ex-lover: it was his set-up left her to be gang-raped by Yakuza punks, and it was a flunked attempt at retribution by Matsu that landed her in a barbarically authoritarian house of corrections.
Based on a popular manga by Toru Shinohara, the Scorpion series was transmitted to celluloid with its pulp origins (virtues and limitations) very much intactâ€”there isnâ€™t a single character anywhere in these films whose psychology might chafe at the limitations of a comic frame. Iâ€™ve now watched four films starring Sasori, and I could tell you remarkably little about her as a human being aside from her superhuman capacity for absorbing, thriving on, honing, and venting hatred, her penchant for visualizing orgasm as a gradually spreading red blob, and her physical description. Oh, and she seems to have a taste for coutureâ€”itâ€™s one of the seriesâ€™ most comic book-y conceits that whenever Matsu busts out, she never wastes time in reassembling her favorite costume, a belted black coat and floppy, broad-brimmed hat that make her look like sheâ€™s just stepped out of a Seventies Vogue spread.
More a monument than a person, thenâ€”the comparison has been made between Kajiâ€™s persona and that of the Easter Island-headed Eastwood of the Man With No Name years, and itâ€™s an apt one, thanks to one of the largest modifications in Scorpionâ€™s big-screen reinvention, which came at the behest of the actress. Instead of the steady rumble of cusses emitted by Shinoharaâ€™s pen-and-ink heroine, Kaji petitioned to play as near as possible to mute; the iconographic image that resulted is Sasori staring, mouth pert, head lowered, eyes burning intent in the wisp of her face between the glossy curtains of her hair. This Scorpionâ€™s a quiet, cunning assassinâ€”not particularly strong or quick or even skilled with her weaponâ€¦ but exceptionally patient, nurtured by rage, and with a lethal gift of knowing just when to slip in the shiv.
Kaji supplied those lovely, snarling eyes; the seriesâ€™ director, first-timer Shunya Ito, supplied flair to fairly rote women-in-prison material: the debut film, Female Prisoner #701: Scorpion, is all glistening tits, ritualistic work-detail punishments, and sadistic hazing, but there are bravura moments of theatricality to be found, among them a rape flashback that plays like a nightclub stage show, replete with rotating walls. The following installment, Female Prisoner #701 Scorpion: Jailhouse 41, confirms the presence of some kind of formidable imagination. Itoâ€™s plastic set-piece sensibility puffs up a fast-nâ€™-nasty exploitation number into an imagist epic of elemental tragedy: a casual murder can stain an entire waterfall with blood; the silent death of an old woman can trigger a split-second change of seasons.
Media Blasters/ Tokyo Shock, who brought the first film of the Scorpion series its U.S. DVD debut, now fill out the domestic disc availability of the Kaji Scorpion films with two exemplary new transfersâ€”Imageâ€™s old Jailhouse 41 release, struck from grubby-looking materials, is unfortunately out of print, and pricey used. Beast Roomâ€”which picks up with Scorpion on the looseâ€”retains most elements of the serialâ€™s established template: one particularly vehement enemy is assigned to Matsu, and theyâ€™ll mutually smolder in dreams of revenge through most of the filmâ€™s runtime. Along the way, sheâ€™ll cull a single trusted female friend from the mire of humanity. The enemy is a Metropolitan Tokyo detective (Mikio Narita) who gets the drop on an at-large Sasori on the subway, slaps handcuffs on her, and loses both the cuffs and his attached arm for his trouble. The friend is a self-employed hooker (Yayoi Watanabe) who submits to numbly sympathy-fucking her brain-damaged big brother in off hours away from the garish entertainment district.
While a graphic limb-lopping and an act of incest within the first reel may be enough to brand this production extravagantly grotesque to some sensibilities, I should note that itâ€™s in fact the most contemplative entry in the series. A first in the Scorpion films are Beast Roomâ€™s downbeat passagesâ€”Matsu and her girlfriend watching trains from an overpass to the limp of Shunsuke Kikuchiâ€™s twilit score is luxuriously melancholy. But soon enough weâ€™re ushered into the titular chamber, a back-room kept by a sadistic Madame (Reisen Lee, who, with her taste for green eyeshade and Space Empress-style gowns, looks like an unconvincing 22nd-Century tranny with an overbite), whose menagerie includes vats of eels, caged blackbirds, and a gaggle of pimps with eyesore suits, and the genital mutilation, strong-armed late-term abortions, and vendettas kick off in turn.
The world which Matsu inhabits is ostensibly Japan circa â€™72â€”the series first installment begins with a guard commendation ceremony, placing it â€ś27 years after the warâ€ťâ€”but thereâ€™s a post-apocalyptic air to the Scorpion films. The melodramatic, burbling David O. Selznick sunsets that Ito favors seem pestilent; the rocky, volcanic terrain that the prisoners pickaxe in Jailhouse 41 seems like the crust of a dead planet. We might be more accurate in assuming, however, that the Scorpion series takes place in the same universe as so many of the films collected under the broad assignation of â€śexploitationâ€ť: The Worst of All Possible Worlds. The representative authority figures, in prison and outside, are grafting sadists. The men we meet are buffonish salarymen, chintzy pimpsâ€”and every last one of them needs only a glimpse of opportunity to become a rapist. Is the indomitable Matsu a feminist heroine? Iâ€™m sure most â€śTake back the nightâ€ť feminists wouldâ€™ve objected to attaching that assignation to something as scurrilous as these WIP flicks, but the irony is that I canâ€™t think of many other artworks that so closely approximate that most vehement strain of Andrea Dworkin/ Katherine MacKinnon feminismâ€™s conception of the battle of the sexes as a real pitched warfare.
But even if the suggestion of these films, made explicit in a ceremonial song interlude in Jailhouse 41, is that â€śwomen commit crimes because of men,â€ť the Scorpion movies, particularly the first two installments, never display a particularly charitable view of those women, either. When the guards arenâ€™t dispensing the abuse, the shrill, scapegoating prisoners take over; any position of power or strength in numbers is promptly misused. Thereâ€™s an oblique anti-authoritarianism at work in these filmsâ€”Ito rarely misses an opportunity to symbolically frame a Japanese flagâ€”but as nearly everyone onscreen seems bereft of the most basic human concern or decency (hardly anyone turns around to see a woman running past with a severed arm handcuffed to her!), itâ€™s difficult to imagine anything clearing the overwhelming social malaise outside of the solution which Sasori undertakes: mass extermination.
Grudge Song (the literal translation of the seriesâ€™ themeâ€”â€śUrami-bushiâ€ť), the last Scorpion film with Kaji, is the first in the series not to be handled by Ito; former Seijun Suzuki protĂ©gĂ© Yasuharu Hasebe (probably best-known, if at all, for his debut, 1966â€™s jukebox-colored Go-Go spy flick, Black Tight Killers), whoâ€™d previously directed Kaji in Nikkatsuâ€™s Stray Cat Rock girl-gang series, slipped into the directorâ€™s chair. The anarchic rage is marginally more focused here: Matsu, on the lam again, is sheltered by a former student insurgent now working the lighting at a sex clubâ€”heâ€™s been especially at odds with the police since they sizzled his manhood with the boiling contents of a tea kettle during an interrogation; notable for series fans is that this is the first time that once-bitten Sasori allows a man her trust. As pursuit and carnage ensue, Itoâ€™s inventive theatricality is sorely missed; Grudge Song moves like a pretty standard Seventies action vehicle of emphatic snap zooms, catchily canted widescreen set-ups, and standard-issue fuzz-tone guitars (Hajime Kaburagiâ€™s unremarkable music replaces that of Kikuchi, whoâ€™d composed such clever, emotive scores for the first three Scorpion films). Itâ€™s never less than watchable stuff (unless, say, you have some compunction about seeing pregnant women tumbling off apartment tower balconies), but whereas the evolution in the prior three Scorpion movies illustrates the ideal effect of serialized worksâ€”the simultaneous pleasures of recognition and expansionâ€”Grudge Song seems merely familiar.